Clone a Drive with Bad Sectors: Data Salvage Guide Based on Reddit Wisdom

A step-by-step guide to cloning a failing drive with bad sectors. Learn about sector-by-sector cloning tools, data recovery software, and how to maximize your chances of a successful clone.

Bad sectors are among the most common yet most frustrating problems for hard drives. When your hard drive starts making unusual noises, experiencing slow read speeds, or causing frequent system crashes, bad sectors are likely the culprit. This article delves into real discussions from Reddit and other professional communities, combining with practical experience from data recovery experts to provide you with an ultimate guide to recover data from a disk with bad sectors.

Why Bad Sectors Cause Conventional Cloning Methods to Fail

Normally, cloning a drive (or creating an image) is simply a matter of "read from source, write to target." But when the source drive has bad sectors, several key challenges arise:

• The bad sectors may be unreadable (resulting in I/O errors, CRC failures, or hanging timeouts), causing the cloning tool to hang or abort.
• Some cloning tools will fail immediately when encountering read errors and lack mechanisms to skip or retry.
• Even tools that support skipping bad sectors may still result in partially corrupted files or missing data blocks.
• Because bad sectors are a physical issue, the target drive does not automatically inherit the same bad sectors. However, if you use a "sector‑by‑sector clone" mode, you may copy over file system metadata, bad block markers, fragmented data, or corrupted file system structures.
• If you do extensive scanning or repeated reads during cloning, you may accelerate further degradation of the source drive (especially for mechanical disks or drives nearing end-of-life).

Bad sectors are categorized into physical bad sectors and logical bad sectors. Physical bad sectors represent actual damage to the disk surface, while logical bad sectors are typically caused by software errors or sudden power loss. Regardless of type, when cloning tools encounter these areas, they can get stuck in repetitive read attempts, eventually causing the process to hang or fail.

Therefore, cloning a disk with bad sectors requires extra caution, a clear strategy, and robust tools.

What Community Says - Real User Experiences

Below are some excerpts and analyses from real discussions on Reddit and related communities, illustrating common problems users face when trying to clone drives with bad sectors.

1️⃣Any chance of cloning a hard drive with bad sectors?

2️⃣What is the best way to clone a disk with bad sectors?

3️⃣Can any software clone a hard drive with bad sectors?

4️⃣Do bad sectors carry over to a cloned SSD?

5️⃣Clone or image a hard drive with bad sectors?

6️⃣How do I clone a disk drive with bad sectors?

These user experiences teach us: You can clone a hard drive with bad sector with a reliable and decent tool, but:

• Don't blindly trust any cloning tool's marketing claims about "bad sector support."
• Always back up critical data before attempting cloning.
• Monitor progress, be prepared for errors, interruptions, retries, or fallback strategies.
• After cloning, verify and repair any inconsistencies.

Share this article on social media to help more people clone a disk with bad sectors.

Essential Tool List: Real Reviews from Communities

Regular file copying is ineffective here. You need professional tools that support sector-by-sector cloning or handle read/write errors. Based on real-world community feedback, here is a list of the tools you can use to recover or clone a hard drive with bad sectors.

#1: ddrescue - Reddit's Tool of Choice

ddrescue is a widely used open-source tool for Linux in the disk recovery/cloning domain, optimized for handling read errors. It can be used to create a complete image of a failing drive, which can then be transferred to a new, healthy drive.

Its intelligent algorithm first attempts to read the easy sections before handling the difficult sections. Unlike the regular dd command, it features multiple retry mechanisms and progress saving functionality, allowing you to resume from where you left off, even if the process is interrupted.

#2: HDDSuperClone - Graphical Professional Tool

HDDSuperClone is an advanced Linux-based hard drive cloning/imaging tool. For users who are uncomfortable with command-line interfaces, HDDSuperClone offers a graphical interface with even more powerful features. It includes multiple recovery algorithms that dynamically adjust strategies based on drive conditions.

#3: Clonezilla - Rescue Mode with Bad Sector Handling Modules

Clonezilla is a popular cloning/backup solution and offers a "rescue" mode for dealing with disks containing bad sectors. While Clonezilla itself has limited capabilities for handling bad sectors, adding advanced parameters can significantly improve its performance.

#4: EaseUS Disk Copy - Clone Disk with Sector-by-Sector Clone

EaseUS Disk Copy can clone a drive with bad sectors by using its "sector-by-sector clone" feature, which skips bad sectors instead of interrupting the process with errors. This allows you to create a full copy of the good data onto a new drive, effectively bypassing the bad sectors and helping to preserve your files from a potentially failing hard disk.

#5 Macrium Reflect - Image Disk with "Ignore Bad Sectors" Option

Macrium Reflect cannot reliably clone a drive with bad sectors because a direct sector-by-sector clone will fail when it encounters a corrupted sector. However, you can use Macrium Reflect's imaging feature by enabling the "Ignore bad sectors" option in the advanced settings.

Step-by-Step Guide: Cloning a Drive with Bad Sectors

The following are general steps for cloning using professional tools.

Stage 1. Before Cloning: Preparation & Risk Assessment

1. Back up critical files immediately. Don't wait until cloning finishes to find files missing. First, copy out irreplaceable data (work files, photos, databases) via file-level methods or recovery tools.

2. Stop all write operations on the source drive. Avoid installing software, system updates, moving large files, etc. Write activity may trigger further damage or expand bad regions.

3. Run SMART/health checks. Use smartctl (Linux/macOS) or CrystalDiskInfo (Windows) to inspect metrics like Reallocated Sector Count, Pending Sector Count, and Uncorrectable Sectors. Sudden rises or high values may indicate imminent failure.

4. Prepare the target drive

• The target should have capacity ≥ used space of the source (or at least total capacity)
• For SSD, ensure write endurance, proper alignment, and TRIM support
• If your PC has only one slot, use a USB docking station or USB to SATA adapter cable to connect it to your PC.

5. Prepare a safe environment/boot medium/live OS. If the source drive is no longer bootable or the OS volume is compromised, prepare a Linux live USB, WinPE boot disk, or use another machine to perform cloning.

Stage 2. Start Cloning: Tool Selection & Parameter Tuning

Using ddrescue or HDDSuperClone requires booting into a Linux environment, which is complicated for most PC users. Here, I will use EaseUS Disk Copy, a user-friendly tool, to clone a hard drive with bad sectors.

Step 1. Run cloning software. Launch EaseUS Disk Copy and choose Disk Mode.

Step 2. Select source and target disks. Select the old drive as the source disk and the new disk as the target.

Note: Check the Enable advanced mode box to access the advanced cloning options, such as Auto 4K SSD Alignment and Sector-by-sector copy.

Step 3. Adjust disk layout. Choose Copy as the source and check the Sector-by-sector copy box to allow for a sector-by-sector clone.

Step 4. Start the process. Confirm the cloning selections and start cloning.

The software will identify the bad sectors and skip them during the cloning process, creating a copy of the healthy data onto the new drive.

Stage 3. After Cloning: Verification, Repair & Recovery Strategies

Even if cloning completes, you can't immediately trust the target drive-there may be missing or corrupted data, file system inconsistencies, or leftover bad-block markers.

1. Comparative verification/difference checks

• If your log tracks bad sectors, try to recover data from those sectors individually.
• Use rsync -c (Linux) or Windows checksum tools to compare file checksums (e.g., SHA1 / MD5) between source and target.
• Run file system integrity checks (e.g., chkdsk /f, fsck) on the target.
• Where feasible, boot from the target drive or test it in real operation.

2. Repairing file system errors

• For partitions on the target, run chkdsk /f, sfc, fsck, etc.
• If some partitions/filesystems are unrepairable, recover file-by-file from backup or from the original drive.
• For bad-block metadata flags that were copied, consider clearing them or rebuilding the file system (once data is safe).

3. Switching the target into use

• After confirming the target drive is stable and consistent, replace the original drive or set the target as the boot drive.
• Continue SMART monitoring and regular backups of the new drive.
• Deploy a backup or imaging regime to mitigate future failure risk.

Share this article on social media to help more people clone a disk with bad sectors.

Common Issues & Pitfalls (FAQs)